CSC/ECE 517 Fall 2009/wiki2pthelm

Reflection-Oriented Programming

Concepts

Reflection-Oriented Programming (ROP), or "reflective programming", is defined as a programming model design with the intent to analyze and improve it's structure, performance or other implementation aspects during runtime (implying no prior knowledge of the source), as opposed to compile time. ROP is a natural extension to object-oriented programming.

Concepts

Two key concepts of ROP are meta-information, which is the state of the program at execution time, and metaprogramming, which is the idea that a language can act as it's own reflection. In other words, a language can reflect (modify) itself. More precisely, we define reflection-oriented programming to be a programming style that uses any means available (reflection or otherwise) to extend the meta-information in order to avoid situations in which a local program's requirements leads to non-local rewriting of said program [4]. Additionally, the ROP concepts extends reflection, in that it can make decisions on the architecture of the system, rather than just methods and variables.

Reflection vs. ROP

Reflection is the process by which a computer program can observe and modify it's own structure and behavior[1]. It allows an executing program to examine or "introspect" upon itself, and manipulate internal properties of the program[2]. Java, Ruby and .NET are among the most popular reflective languages, however there are many others[3]. Although reflection is the primary concept behind ROP, it does not necessarily preclude the existence of ROP. ROP is a concept of design; as with most designs, it is not necessarily dependent on the implementation. As an example, computational programming can also be used to implement the concepts of ROP, and does not assume the presence of source code at runtime, something that is essential to the concept of reflection[4].

The ROP metaprogramming model sequences are defined as either atomic (simple) or compound (multi-atomic). These sequences take advantage of meta-information that retains knowledge of program structure, which is different than a classic object-oriented program that can lose said structure after compilation.

Meta-Information

Meta-Information, or metadata, is the state of the program at execution time. Phrased another way, Meta-information is information about information. For example, a if a document is considered to be information, its title, location, and subject are examples of meta-information[5]. Meta-Information is essential not only for reflection but for the concepts of ROP to be implemented correctly.

Metaprogramming

Metaprogramming introduces the concept of "programs that write programs". Reflection is one type of metaprogramming, and therefore can be considered as an option when attempting to design a system or program based on the concepts defined by ROP. Metaprograms are written in Metalanguage[6], which to be considered for ROP would be defined as the same or alternate language as the system or program to be implemented.

Examples

Simple Reflection

As an example, first let us review what reflection looks like as an implementation. To see how reflection works, consider this simple example:

  import java.lang.reflect.*;

  public class DumpMethods {
     public static void main(String args[])
     {
        try {
           Class c = Class.forName(args[0]);
           Method m[] = c.getDeclaredMethods();
           for (int i = 0; i < m.length; i++)
           System.out.println(m[i].toString());
        }
        catch (Throwable e) {
           System.err.println(e);
        }
     }
  }

For an invocation of:

 java DumpMethods java.util.Stack

the output is:

 public java.lang.Object java.util.Stack.push(
   java.lang.Object)
  public synchronized 
    java.lang.Object java.util.Stack.pop()
  public synchronized
     java.lang.Object java.util.Stack.peek()
  public boolean java.util.Stack.empty()
  public synchronized 
    int java.util.Stack.search(java.lang.Object)

That is, the method names of class java.util.Stack are listed, along with their fully qualified parameter and return types.

This program loads the specified class using class.forName, and then calls getDeclaredMethods to retrieve the list of methods defined in the class. java.lang.reflect.Method is a class representing a single class method. Reflection is useful because it supports dynamic retrieval of information about classes and data structures by name, and allows for their manipulation within an executing program[2].

ROP

ROP is more than just simple reflection (although technically, it can be reflection alone), it is also analyzation or improvement at runtime without prior knowledge of source. A good example of this concept is Measuring Computational Expense. To implement such behavior, we need only these definitions:

 define reflective <runtime> (<simple-reflective>)
 slot ticks, init-value: 0;
 end;

 define method atomic (v, outer :: <runtime>)
 update(outer, ticks: add1(outer.ticks))
 end;

 define method compound-initial (outer :: <runtime>)
 update(outer, ticks: add1(outer.ticks))
 end;

It is convenient to have default behaviors for atomic, compound-initial, and compound-rest that simply "thread" meta-information through the computations. The inherited definition of compound-rest suffices. Now suppose we want to evaluate some expression E without counting its cost. We could use the reify and reflect operations like this:

 let r = reify(<runtime>);
 let result = E;
 reflect(<runtime>, r, result);

Here we capture the expense meta-information before evaluating E and save it as r. After evaluating E, we restore the old meta-information. The result from evaluating E is returned. Of course, any time we want to know the cumulative expense for the program, we can examine reify(<runtime>).ticks[4].

Java and Ruby are two examples of popular programming languages that are inherently reflective, and therefore could be used to implement an ROP paradigm.

References

[1] Reflection (Computer Science), Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflection_%28computer_science%29
[2] Using Java Reflection, Sun: http://java.sun.com/developer/technicalArticles/ALT/Reflection/
[3] List of reflective programming languages and platforms, Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_reflective_programming_languages_and_platforms
[4] An Introduction to Reflection-Oriented Programming, Sobel & Friedman: http://www2.parc.com/csl/groups/sda/projects/reflection96/docs/sobel/sobel.pdf
[5] What is Metainformation?: http://searchoracle.techtarget.com/sDefinition/0,,sid41_gci900705,00.html
[6] Metaprogramming, Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metaprogramming