CSC/ECE 517 Fall 2012/ch1 1w22 an

From PG_Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search



A method that belongs to a class is called by creating an object of the class and passing the method name to the object as a message. The object then looks up the method lookup path and tries to match the called method with the defined methods in the class. On success, the method is executed and the result is returned.

If the object does not find a match in its method lookup, in normal circumstances the NoMethodError Exception is raised .

In cases where the user wants to handle the methods which are not defined but are still called, “method_missing” can be defined and the user can handle the methods as he/she sees fit.

Format for Defining method_missing

=> def method_missing(m,*args,&block)

(i) m-> accepts the symbol/name of the undefined method (ii) *args-> accepts the array of arguments passed in the method call (iii) &block->accepts a block passed to the method

Ruby Method Lookup Flow

When the object of a class receives a method name to be executed, the following steps are carried out for matching and executing the method:

This entire tracing that the object does is called the method lookup path.


Calling Defined and Undefined Methods

class A		// creating a class 'A'
def say		// defining a method 'say'
puts " say Hi " // body of method say

Creating the object of the class	       // object of the class
 => #<A:0x2a082e0>     //object id

Calling the defined method

a.say                  // defined method
=> say Hi	       // returned result

Calling the undefined method

a.sayhi                // undefined method sayhi
NoMethodError: undefined method `sayhi' for #<A:0x2a082e0>   // the NoMethodError is raised

method_missing Implementation[2]

class A
def say
puts " say hi "
def method_missing(m,*args,&block)	// defining method_missing
puts " This method does not exist"	// body of method_missing

Calling a method that is not defined
a.sayhi                                // calling the undefined method sayhi with no arguments
=> This method does not exist		// this result returned when method_missing is executed

When the object 'a' traces its method lookup path for a matching method 'sayhi', upon failure it resorts to method_missing and the body of method_missing is executed.

Sometimes when a class has many methods that do generally the same kinds of functionality, and the programmer is not sure in advance which methods the user will call since there are so many of them, and all of them are similar, writing code for all of the methods seems futile. In these situations method_missing can be defined to take care of these cases. The below 'Generic Handler' example implements this.

Passing Parameters to an Undefined Method Call

class A
def add(a,b)
def method_missing(name,*args,&block)    // the method_missing is defined and the *args parameter accepts all the parameters passed during 								                                 
                                            the method call   
puts “You have typed the method name wrong and these were the parameters passed ; #{args[0]}, #{args[1]}”								

The passed parameters are stored in the array 'args' and can be accessed like a normal array

Calling the defined method

a.add(1,2)		        // calling the defined method add and passing the parameters (1,2)
=> 3                           // result

Calling the undefined method

a.adds(4,2) 			// calling the undefined method adds and passing the parameter (4,2)
=> You have typed the method name wrong and these were the parameters passed; 4, 2

The user made a genuine mistake by typing 'adds', but this method is not defined. When the 'adds' method with parameters is called, the object 'a' tries to match the method in the method lookup path. Upon failure it invokes method_missing, the args are passed, stored in the array 'args' and the body of method_missing is executed.

Converting Numbers from Roman Representation to Integer Representation[3]

class Roman
DIGITS = {'I'=>1,'V'=>5,'X'=>10,'L'=>50,'C'=>100,'D'=>500,'M'=>1000,}
def roman_to_integer(roman_string)
last = nil
roman_string.to_s.upcase.split(//).reverse.inject(0) do
|memo, digit|
if digit_value = DIGITS[digit]
if last && last > digit_value
memo -= digit_value
memo += digit_value
last = digit_value
def method_missing(method)

Calling the undefined methods


The Output

=> 7
=> 29
=> 24

method_missing to Log Method Calls[4]

Another application that makes use of method_missing could be a simple logger used for debugging purposes. Many times, it may be required to log the trace of called methods and provide information such as: called method-name, arguments, return type. It can be tedious to repeat this part of code in every method. A simple solution to this problem can be obtained using method_missing as:

 class SimpleCallLogger
 def initialize(o)
 @obj = o
 def method_missing(methodname, *args)
 puts "called: #{methodname}(#{args})"
 a = @obj.send(methodname, *args)
 puts "\t-> returned: #{a}"
 return a

This program makes use of method_missing in a way that it wraps around called method to output the logging information on entry and on exit, it logs the return type. Further, method_missing intercepts the method call and forward it to internal object with ‘send’ method of ruby. Hence, this use of method_missing acts as wrapper.

Generic Handler

class NoBar
def method_missing(methodname, *args)
define_method(:bar) if "bar" == methodname.to_s
define_method(:nobar) if "nobar" == methodname.to_s

This is an example of using method_missing as a generic handler to handle when a calling method is not exist. You can use missing_method to dynamically create a method at a runtime.

Advantages of method_missing

Disadvantages of method_missing

Key Points

class A
@@i = 0
def method_missing(method_id)
puts "In Method Missing #{@@i}"
@@i += 1
a = 


The result is a 'stack level too deep' error. 

When the 'foo' method is called, after no method match the method_missing is run and this block has a method '' that is undefined. Here when the program execution encounters '' it once again calls method_missing. This goes on in an endless loop till the stack memory becomes full.

class A

def method_missing(method_id)
puts "In method_missing"
a =
puts a.respond_to?(:foo)


In method_missing

Similar functionality in other languages

Method missing, one of the dynamic features of Ruby, is not a feature that is unique to Ruby. It exists in Smalltalk, Python, Groovy, some Javascripts and most CLOS (Common Lisp Object System)extensions. In this section we look at the few such similar implementations in other languages. The table below gives different ways the functionality related to method_missing is handled in other languages.[5]

Construct                          Language 
AUTOLOAD                           Perl
__getattr__                        Python
method_missing                     Ruby
doesNotUnderstand                  Smalltalk
__noSuchMethod__(1)                CoffeeScript, JavaScript
unknown                            Tcl
no-applicable-method               Common Lisp
doesNotRecognizeSelector           Objective-C
TryInvokeMember(2)                 C#
match [name, args] { ... }         E
the predicate fail                 Prolog
forward                            Io

(1) supported by Firefox

(2) only for dynamic objects

Table Reference[6]


This method is called when an attribute lookup has not found the attribute in the usual places i.e. it is not an instance attribute nor is it found in the class tree for self. name is the attribute name. This method should return the (computed) attribute value or raise an AttributeError exception.

class Roman(object):

 def roman_to_int(self, roman):
   # implementation here
 def __getattr__(self, name):
   return self.roman_to_int(name)

>>> r = Roman()

>>> r.iv


In SmalltalkLanguage When a receiver is asked to perform a method that is unknown to it, then a run-time complaint is issued which is #doesNotUnderstand. When a Smalltalk object is sent a message for a method it has not defined, the runtime system turns the message-send into an object and sends #doesNotUnderstand: to the original receiver with this message-send object as argument. By default the #doesNotUnderstand: method raises an exception, but the receiver can override it and implement it in a way that he sees fit.

JavaScript also has a method which has an implementation similar to that of method_missing and that is "noSuchMethod". The limitation of this method is that it is only supported by Firefox/Spidermonkey.

Similarly, Perl has an AUTOLOAD method which works on subroutines & class/object methods.

Patterns of method missing[9]

Now that we have covered all the important areas about method missing including the advantages, the disadvantages and key points related to its functionality, it would be appropriate to know about the different ways method_missing is used and what are the consequences of its use.

Well as method missing is called when there is no object to handle the method being called, we can use method_missing to include more information about the reasons for it being called, i.e. to say that we can provide users with more information about the error messages and hence make the life of the programmers easy and provide a faster way to solve the bugs.

Instead of sending method as explicit parameters, another method is to use the name to encode parameters. Find below a Rails-style find expression: Person.find_by_name_and_age("ABC",30) Another way of writing the same: Person.find_by(:name => "ABC", :age => 30)

The disadvantage of this is that creating such kind of API's make it difficult to debug and maintain the application.

The idea of a builder is that you use Ruby’s blocks and method_missing to make it easy to create any kind of output structure. You create a builder object and then send it messages and it responds to the messages by building up a data structure based on those messages. For example, the following code

 builder ="", 2)
 puts builder.person {
   phone("12345", "local"=>"yes")

will print

   <phone local="yes">12345</phone>

Here we have defined a method_missing method and it handles any undefined method and adds the name of the method to the XML markup that is being built. Code blocks are used to capture the nested nature of the XML. The result is a very natural way to programmatically generate XML markup. Also the cumbersome task of closing the tags and escaping rules are taken care of for us.

The inversion of the builder pattern is to use a parser that goes through the XML document and then allow access to the elements by using method_missing.

Different kind of test helpers can be created using method_missing. Many of the open source Ruby projects implementations of method missing are found in the tests.


method_missing is a very powerful feature of Ruby and as is the way with powerful things it can help you a great deal if used properly but it can make things a lot harder for you if implemented incorrectly. It is a kind of a feature which should be used sparingly, if not at all. And there are things that needs to be taken into consideration, as mentioned in the Key Points section above, if method_missing is to be implemented.



Further Suggested Reading

Personal tools